I must admit I got smacked when I was younger and I dont think it made me a bad person or affected me in any majot way but I totally dont agree with smacking like that...
These days Zaara has learned to scratch if she gets mad and after telling her NO and she still does it...I smack her hand lightly....she looks at me and just goes on playing......untill the next day at kindy....arrrggg
But I promised myself that no matter what I will never hit my kids in a manner that they remember it for the rest of their life...I remember all of my major smacks!!