nz idol - just plain mean

I didn't see it - who made the final 10?

I haven't watched any of NZ Idol this time around...I'm sorry but I can't really see what a radio DJ who says he knows nothing and a one hit wonder girl have to offer in the way of expert judging.

I also got sick of how cruel they could be to people.

At least it means it's a good time to jump on Oh Baby instead!

Jennz, my sister's flatmate love that X factor, they were singing along when she rang me yesterday morning (so Sunday night your time). Have to say I don't like the new judges - Stables really doesn't have the "it thing" to be a judge, he took over from Paul who was a music mananger he knew what he was talking about. Jacqui was lovely but had her reasons to leave but so can't stand that true bliss chicky.

Yeah I hate the new judges Megan thinks shes so great but shes nothing. She was so mean to Ashlee I think she was jealous of her. The wildcards should of got to sing another song and there should of been a few more.

I think the judges suck, surely there must have been better qualified people out there. That stables just needs to grow up, he's not funny at all and well where is True Bliss now, just goes to show she doesnt know anything about the industry. Its funny watching little old nz idol compared to Rockstar Supernova, they are all good performers and its fun to watch, nz idol seems so ametur (sp) compared.

gsmum wrote: now i normally only watch the beginning of the series cause its funny, and then maybe the last couple of episodes but after tonight i dont think i will bother at all. To me i am finding the judges really cruel... and the audiences too, all that booing while the judges are talking... grrr. and tonight that guy who was put thru to the wildcard didnt even get a chance to practice, just thrown in the deep end... grrrrr.

I think you'll find that they all would of practised as who ever made it through had to sing again.

Anyway.... he made into the final 10 so he didnt do too badly!


Did anyone read the magazine article about stables having the stroke right after the show?

Trish

I cannot believe that guy didnt get through. It was between him and Ashlee. I cant remember his name, ummmm what was it. He was the best outta all of them really. He reminded me of Nik from last show. His name is on the tip of my tongue awwwwww ummmmm......

OK so must admit to being secretly in love with Frankie Stevens But Maya's godmother told Willie he looks like FRankie Stevens, and his head grew about 4 sizes lol...

Anyways, did anyone else pick up last night that Frankie and Stables don't like Megan and she doesn't like them? IMO that was more entertaining than the performances...

Oh and I listen to Stables every afternoon on my way to pick up Maya from preschool. The guy is crude and nasty and neanderthal - but sooooooo funny!

Im boycotting Idol from now on - the MC from my wedding is Cams dad - and we all love his singing (we even played one of his songs for his dad at the wedding to thank him)....Cam has won so many awards including the golden guitars etc, sung with Topp twins at Tamworth, in shows etc ...and THEN the judges chose his song, told them how to arrange it and literally picked him to pieces saying how bad it was - and Frankie told him not to over perform, so he didnt, and then Frankie told him he hated country music - so Cam hasnt sung any country (only one of his abilities) and then the poodle comment was sooo unecessary...when Cam didnt get through I couldnt beleive it - he is so much more talented than some who did and he did all the judges wanted!
And then to read that becs is one of the Mermaids - I mean they are a professional singer group AND one of the members is Jo Cotton from True Bliss....anyone smell anything BAD!!!!
Im over idol - I was hoping it would go for greater things this year (and not just Cam) but they will have another flop on their hands....UGH!

Edited by Bombshell

I cant believe Victor got voted out! I thought he was so much better then ashlee! what are people thinking!!!
LOL